Welcome to Scarpellino's Restaurant and Catering
Scarpellino's Restaurant and Catering, located on Forbes Avenue in New Haven, CT, is a beloved family-owned gem celebrated for its authentic Italian flavors and inviting atmosphere. They offer a delightful range of comforting breakfast options, including freshly baked bagels and muffins, alongside hearty salads and signature sandwiches like their famed meatballs and steak and cheese subs. Patrons rave about the love and pride infused into each dish, reminiscent of classic Italian delis. With an emphasis on scratch cooking and quick service, Scarpellino's has become a cherished spot where delicious food and a friendly vibe unite, making every visit memorable.
-
257 Forbes Ave #1, New Haven, CT 06512, United States257 Forbes Ave #1, New Haven, CT 06512, United States Hotline: +1 203-468-7827
Welcome to Scarpellino's Restaurant and Catering, a delightful gem situated in the heart of New Haven, Connecticut. This family-owned establishment boasts a warm and inviting atmosphere that reflects the love for authentic Italian cuisine. Located at 257 Forbes Ave #1, Scarpellino's has become a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike, known for its hearty meals and welcoming service.
As you step inside, the aroma of freshly prepared dishes fills the air, promising a culinary experience that showcases the essence of Italian cooking. From delightful breakfast favorites like Danny's Eggs Benedict to satisfying lunch options such as juicy meatballs and savory Italian sausage, every plate at Scarpellino's is crafted with care and dedication. The authentic flavors are a testament to the owners, Luann and Danny, who pour their passion into every dish.
Highlights of the menu include the famous Wednesday special featuring fresh chicken cutlets, beloved by many as the best in town. Patrons often reminisce about the days when sandwiches were made with locally sourced ingredients and classic Italian bread—a nostalgic experience that Scarpellino's delivers with aplomb. The Italian Tortellini Salad, a delightful mix of salami, cheese tortellini, and roasted peppers, and the Tuna Macaroni Salad, made with creamy mayo and tender pasta, are perfect sides that reflect the restaurant's commitment to quality.
But don’t just take my word for it; the feedback from loyal customers echoes a similar sentiment. Many rave about the 'greasy spoon' charm and the dual magic of comfort food and genuine hospitality. Scarpellino’s isn’t merely a place to eat; it’s where the community gathers, friendships flourish, and flavors dance in harmony.
So, whether you are in the mood for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, come and experience the rich tapestry of flavors at Scarpellino's Restaurant and Catering. Your taste buds will thank you.
There are so many great items here that it would take me all day to score them highly. But my favorite is on Wednesdays and fresh chicken cutlets, the best I’ve found locally to date. Think back going to your local Italian owned deli when the sandwich tasted awesome and your jaw hurt from that classic locally made Italian bread. If you’re a fan of broccoli rabe, Try Danny’s . Even the breakfast options are great.
Best “greasy spoon” Italian lunch counter this side of the Mississippi! Meatballs were juicy and rich with real (scratch cooking) flavor. Italian sausage was equally good, with fennel and very pleasant little kick. Peppers available for more kick! Wife would eat here every day. 90% of customers are greater by name and get their “usual” without opening their mouth.
Great little diner with just as good of atmosphere. This was our first time eating here. The food was amazing! Definitely taste the love put into it.
Amazing family owned deli/ restaurant. The atmosphere is upbeat and cozy. Every time I eat here the food is made quickly and it’s always delicious- Great portions. Luann and Danny (owners) are the sweetest. They have different authentic Italian dishes as well as a wide variety of subs and sandwiches. My favorite spot for a steak and cheese sub or some eggplant with a side of ziti. Never been disappointed.
What they have is pride. You listen to them talk about the food, their specials, etc. they care. And you can taste it. Fancy - no. Delicious- yes. With a lie lot of items you can’t get at a traditional deli, much less one of the chains.
Excellent selection of delicious lunch options including daily specials! The staff is friendly and know many customers by name. Food is fresh and service is quick. It is popular for takeout as parking and seating is a bit limited. I will definitely be back.
I’ve visited this place for many years! Food it’s always fresh & delicious! Owners always friendly, and great atmosphere!
Great People The best scrambled eggs with ham cheese and home fries I ever ate. Rye toast was delicious and so was the coffee This is a must stop and eat at restaurant. You will love this place ...